Variant 2 · Two tabs + inline can't-swap

9:415G 🔋

‹ Substitutions

📦 6 of 8 eligible items will be replaced if out of stock

Replace 6

Don't replace 2

🍜

Lipton Noodle Soup Mix

4.5 oz

Replace

🐟

Sam's Choice Mahi-Mahi

12 oz

Replace

🧴

Ajax Ultra Dish Soap

28 fl oz

Replace

🥣

Honey Nut Cheerios

18.8 oz

Replace

🍌

Organic Bananas

bunch

Replace

🍅

Roma Tomatoes

1 lb

Replace

🥛

Great Value Whole Milk

1 gal

Don't replace

🥚

Eggland's Best Large Eggs

12 ct

Don't replace

🔒 2 items can't be swapped

🍺

Coors Light · 6 pack

Alcohol can't be substituted

💊

Bayer Low Dose Aspirin

Medication can't be substituted

Two tabs + inline can't-swap

Variant 2 of 3

What changed

Drops the "All" tab — the persistent total already answers the count, so the tabs hold only the two things the customer actually decides: Replace and Don't replace. The two items that can't be swapped move to a quiet, always-visible inline section at the bottom (not a tab).

What was kept

Decision-based tabs, per-tab counts, persistent total, inline per-item editing.

Findings addressed

F4 · only the customer's two real choicesQ · "All" tab redundant

Trade-off

Can't-swap items are less prominent — fine if they're rare, but a customer scanning fast might miss why alcohol/meds aren't in a tab. Variant 3 makes the whole breakdown explicit up front.